Staging inquiry | Operations | Forum

Welcome to the ProTrak User Community Support Forum . The forum is designed around the chapters in The Manual. Please post your questions in the appropriate subforums. You may "Subscribe" to topics and reply by email.

A A A
Avatar

Please consider registering
guest

sp_LogInOut Log In sp_Registration Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —






— Match —





— Forum Options —





Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

sp_Feed Topic RSS sp_Print sp_TopicIcon
Staging inquiry
September 29, 2020
10:21 am
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Hello all.

after getting very frustrated with the program over a year ago I have come back to try again. My layout is unique as there is no physical staging track. All my outside world cars come on to and leave the layout by barge. (Think cassettes on British layouts) From the barge(s) the cars go to various drawers under the layout for storage until needed again. What would be the best way for cars to enter and leave the layout in the program? 

second question 

is there any documentation on the dispatcher options? I see options for Tt&to and TWC but no sign of application. At the moment we are using OCS (the Canadian version of TWC) but as sessions start again after Covid, hoping to slowly work towards TT&TO as experience grows. 

September 29, 2020
4:16 pm
Avatar
Joe-SVL
32826
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 243
Member Since:
April 26, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Hey Michael good to see you back again.

wrt Barges (Car floats) there is something in ProTrak but right now I cannot find it. I have a beautiful car float on my layout with long term plans to use the car float to take cars on and off my layout but not specifically as a staging track substitute. My car float would simulate cars being sent up river to small non-railroad towns and returning. Presently I do not have that capability working. I just spent some time looking thru ProTrak but I cannot find what I was looking for. As I recall there is a capability somewhere in ProTrak to put cars on a car float (not a cross river type car float) and then to tell ProTrak that the car float has "sailed". This, as I recall, is the way that ProTrak knows that the cars are not on the layout which somewhat answers your first question.  There are two ProTrak users up in Toronto and I know one of them uses car floats. Hopefully they are still active on this forum and will respond with their knowledge.

I cannot help you are all with your 2-nd question.

Joe in Orlando

September 29, 2020
6:48 pm
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I am wondering if the barge option is the best route. The barge operates more like a interchange with the outside world. As roughly half my fleet is in storage at any given time putting cars on a barge in the program to only be unloaded later is not a option. On JMRI I got around this by running a fictional train with all my storage cars from fictional staging A to the barge (interchange) then on to Staging B. Then next session reverse it. The fictional train would only set out the cars to the barge that was needed on the layout and then lift all cars that were spotted there by the yard switcher. 
Micheal

September 29, 2020
7:04 pm
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

The CCR Facebook page because who does like showing off their work sometimes 

https://www.facebook.com/CCRailway/

September 30, 2020
3:38 am
Avatar
John V
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 43
Member Since:
April 26, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Michael,

What you are doing should be covered by using a "car float" and "active staging".

The car float is enabled in Administration->Spot Format And Special Spots".
If I recall correctly ProTrak will route cars to and from the float based on the connection points for the float.
Search the Ops forum for "float" and you will get several post concerning float operations that may help.

You will probably need a fictional train to take the cars from the float to the desired staging track.
Easy to do but you may need a fictional yard to allow proper routing
(I have 2 fictional trains that take cars from 2 interchanges and move them to off layout storage and return when normal unloading is done).

The active staging allows removal of cars from  staging and is setup in Administration->Active Staging Options.
It will also need to be turned on for each desired staging track.
Active staging is discussed in the PTBM App L entry M.15

Hope this helps,

John Valle
Freelanced GN Rachel Branch in '68

September 30, 2020
12:25 pm
Avatar
casowest
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 95
Member Since:
May 8, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

hey, i wrote a long reply to this thread this morning, i previewed it, I moved the pencil to show that i wasn't a robot, and it hasn't shown up.  Just wondering where it is?

Is it in the system somewhere?

John Mitchell

October 1, 2020
8:50 pm
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Sorry I don’t see it either 

October 2, 2020
4:20 pm
Avatar
Joe-SVL
32826
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 243
Member Since:
April 26, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

John V  Thanks for your input but at least in Ver 348. the point you mentioned under Admin / Special SPOTs seems to address car ferries that operate between two points on the main line.  What Cowboy/Michael and I need is the car float operation in which cars are actually removed from the layout and some time later returned to the layout.

John M - thanks for joining the conversation. You are the one I believe with the most ProTrak experience with car floats and I to am anxious to read your thoughts. Somehow we all need to get some of these specialty areas of ProTrak documented for future use. I was a editor with Doug Seymour when he was writing the PTBM so I have some outline sections that he anticipated writing before his health interfered with his absolutely wonderful writing efforts. Car ferries / barges /car floats where to be in Chapter 14.

Michael - You might want to rethink using the car float as a means to simulate staging tracks. If I am correct when a car float "Sails" with car aboard I think those cars then become "inactive" inside ProTrak which means as best I can recall there would be no waybill processing for those cars when the  Daily Summary is run at the end of a session.  With staging tracks the cars that are moved to a staging track as still active cars and waybills are processed for all those cars when the Daily Summary is run.

I sense that your use of a car float might mean that you do not have room physically for staging tracts. If that is correct have you looked into the use of a "transfer table" (I think I have the correct term, any way it does begin with the letter "t".) With a transfer table you could have a whole set of parallel tracks on a movable cart or similar device. When a train is sent to "Staging" you would just align one of the tracks on the table with a piece of track that is actually on you layout, and then run your train onto the table. These cars would still be considered "active" in ProTrak. The transfer table could then be stored on a closet or possibly under the layout. In you next operating session just turn the table around so that the engines are facing your layout. Then when a specific train is scheduled to depart staging just align the track on the table with the track leading up to your main line and carry on. 

 

Joe in Orlando

October 2, 2020
6:04 pm
Avatar
John V
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 43
Member Since:
April 26, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Hi,

Sorry if I was not clear. Yes the car float would run from the on layout terminal to a "fictitious" terminal off layout. A "fictitious" train would then take the cars from the float at a "fictitious" float terminal to a "fictitious" staging track which could use active staging to allow removal of the cars from the layout for a number of sessions. The cars could physically stay on the float or be moved to a drawer as desired. Hopefully John M can assist with the specific mechanics of float ops.
ProTrak should route cars destined for the "fictitious" staging via the float and the "fictitious" train to staging.
Depending on any limits on floats I would expect you could have multiple floats (or float routes) serve multiple "fictitious" staging tracks.

From my own experience "fictitious" trains are pretty easy. I have 2 interchanges with logging railroads. For Each I created a Yd yard and 2 customers (a freight house and a log loading). At the end of each session I run one "fictitious" train for each logging railroad that takes cars from the interchange and delivers them to the "fictitious" customers and returns cars from the "fictitious" customers to the interchange. I crated the "fictitious" Yd yard because it made it easier for the "fictitious" train to route the cars properly. Each logging railroad has 2 stations: the actual  station where its interchange track is and the "fictitious" station where its yard and 2 customers are.
Physically when I run the "fictitious" trains I manually remove the affected cars from the interchange tracks putting them in off layout storage and take the desired cars from the off layout storage placing them on the interchange tracks.

Hope this is a better explanation,

John Valle
Freelanced GN Rachel Branch in '68

October 3, 2020
1:28 am
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

My layout is based on the PGE. Like the PGE my layout has no physical interchanges with the outside rail network. All outside traffic comes on to the layout and leaves by the rail barge. The rail barge is switched by the yard switcher that takes the cars from the rail barge and assembles them in to the train(s) that travels up the short main line. So my layout is very unique as no train goes in to any kind of staging. 

so my challenge is how to work the rail barge. In theory I can call it a customer team track and have all the cars go there, then come off the rail barge again. I could make it a yard track that the yard switcher puts cars in to and pulls others out. While a fictional train pulls the cars from there to a fictional staging. Or a combination of all the above. I find I have to keep 50% of my rail cars in storage or they overwhelm the layout. It would be nice to find a option that naturally cycles cars on to and then off the layout. 

October 4, 2020
3:16 pm
Avatar
John V
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 43
Member Since:
April 26, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Cowboy,

The only method in ProTrak to remove cars from and later return cars to the layout is "Active Staging". There fore you need to get the cars to staging, either actual or "fictitious".

The biggest question I see is how many car float loads arrive an depart per day/session.

- If only once each way and preferably inbound first and outbound later, designating the float as a staging track and running an actual train that takes cars from your "Yd" yard to staging (the float) should work fine except ProTrak will think the loco is on the float (since it is in Staging) even if it actually returns to your engine terminal. Graphically:

station A ---------- sta B ------------Yd yard ----------- Sta C-------- Sta D     (or however your physical layout is setup)
                                                /        \
                   train to staging (float)        train to staging (float)
                                              /            \
                                 Staging (physically your float) - use active staging to remove to and return cars from storage

- If the float has multiple runs or you have multiple floats or multiple other end terminals for the float.
Set up your physical float terminal as one end for multiple floats. Create a "fictitious" terminal, "Yd" yard and staging track for the other end of each float route (the yard and staging and possibly the terminal will be a different railroad {RRA} - not your PGE). Setup "fictitious" RRA trains to move cars to/from your float from/to the "fictitious" RRA Yd yard and a second pair of "fictitious" RRA trains to/from the RRA Yd yard from/to the "fictitious" RRA staging (you may be able to combine these into one pair of trains).
If you have multiple runs of the float between the same terminals then add a second "fictitious" staging track for RRA and a second set of "fictitious" trains to handle the cars.
If you have multiple off layout terminals for the float(s) create multiple sets of "fictitious" terminals, "Yd" yards and staging tracks for RRB, RRC, etc. Graphically:

station A ---------- sta B ------------Yd yard ----------- Sta C-------- Sta D     (or however your physical layout is setup)
                                                    \  
                                             Float Terminal (on Layout)
                                               \           \
                                                \        Float route to RRA terminal
                                                 \           \
                                                  \        RRA float Terminal ("fictitious") --- RRA Yd yard ("fictitious")--- RRA Staging 1 ("fictitious")
                                                   \                                                                                      _____ RRA Staging 2 ("fictitious")
                                                    \
                                                    Float route to RRB terminal
                                                       \
                                                        RRB float Terminal ("fictitious") --- RRB Yd yard ("fictitious") ----- RRB Staging 1 ("fictitious")
                                            .                                                                   .                            _____ RRB Staging 2 ("fictitious")

You would run all the "fictitious" trains between your sessions using active staging to remove and return cars form the layout as desired. If you have multiple physical floats you 'dock' on your layout they can all be preloaded and put in place when the float is due to arrive. If not you will have to place the appropriate cars on the float using the float's switchlist form ProTrakbefore you report the floats arrival at you on layout terminal.

ProTrak should route cars to your float for each staging destination based on your waybills/carorders and overhead traffic setup. At the appropriate time you would run the carfloat (i believe similar to running a train) and take your float off the layout (or unload it manually if only 1 float with multiple runs) before placing the next arriving float in place (or loading it from the next float waybill).

Note: you can use the ("fictitious") RRA setup even if there is only 1 float run per day as it would probably be more realistic paperwork wise than the float as staging approach. You would only need to handle cars between sessions in that case.

I am basing my suggestions on remembering old discussions that the float acted like a connecting 'train' between its 2 terminals. The specifics of how it is loaded and unloaded are not familiar to me, but i do not recall hearing of any issues. Based on my own experience I can not envision any issues over use of fictitious trains, stations, yards, staging and float terminals, but you do need to print the waybills to make sure you get the cars to the correct locations. The same should be true for active staging.

Best,

John Valle
Freelanced GN Rachel Branch in '68

October 4, 2020
10:24 pm
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

I am going to print this out and see if I can make it work. Thank you. The barge gets swapped out between sessions right now. So only one barge per session is correct. 

October 16, 2020
3:05 pm
Avatar
casowest
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 95
Member Since:
May 8, 2015
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

i'm cursed!!!

I logged in, wrote a long reply and i mean long, minimized the app to check something in PT and found that I was logged out by the app and lost all my wonderful insights (!) to setting up the car float and virtual yards, industries, etc

Cowboy, John V. and Joe, if you give me your emails, i promise to replicate it for your info.  Joe, it could be the start of an addition to the Manual.  

Curses, double curses!

John Mitchell

mitchel2 at Rogers.com

October 17, 2020
9:53 am
Avatar
cowboy
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 23
Member Since:
April 27, 2019
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Email sent thank you 

Micheal 

Forum Timezone: America/Chicago

Most Users Ever Online: 189

Currently Online:
13 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
3 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

Nashville: 248

Joe-SVL: 243

casowest: 95

Jim Brewer: 92

Mark Stafflrd: 58

Bob: 53

Fred: 43

John V: 43

jjoyce1: 32

Peter Jackson: 27

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 0

Members: 259

Moderators: 0

Admins: 5

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 13

Topics: 432

Posts: 1815

Newest Members:

Fred52, ferretjack, Frank, bcole_-8@rogers.com, frich1230, waffle2@mac.com, innovativerc@gmail.com, KRFARRINGTON, George Giles, NandWSRY55

Administrators: earlyrail: 71, friscomike: 130, webmaster: 1, hunter48820: 23, Jim Moir: 489